9 Aug Other Losses caused an international scandal when first published in by revealing that Allied Supreme Commander Dwight Eisenhower’s. 17 Apr much controversy among scholars and other interested readers. And yet, James Bacque keeps ferreting out more information that makes his. 30 Aug Other Losses: An Investigation into the Mass Deaths of German Prisoners of War after World War Two by James Bacque Macdonald, pp.
|Genre:||Health and Food|
|Published (Last):||3 September 2010|
|PDF File Size:||8.14 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||12.20 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
I think Mr Hinsley will find himself lonely in bafque belief that the British and Canadian Armies were so much other losses james bacque organised than the Americans that they signally succeeded where the Americans other losses james bacque failed. The book claims that a “Missing Million” prisoners exist in the difference in totals between two U.
That jams kept in storage 13, food parcels, intended for prisoners of war, for seven months, while men starved to death in the foetid muck behind barbed wire?
Since the book was published in Canada, Professor Hans Hoch of the University of York in Other losses james bacque and Professor Peter Hoffman of McGill University other losses james bacque Montreal have both stated that they saw Americans pour gasoline over, then set fire to, piles of food before the eyes of hungry Germans.
Bacque described his other witness, John Foster, as a camp guard “in charge of the work detail of fifty men, Germans and Americans, who did kosses all day but drag bodies out of the camp. The New Orleans panel noted that Lauben himself twice has since repudiated this.
He finds that, on the whole, the dreadful conditions in the US and French camps, which other losses james bacque more or less admits occurred, resulted from misjudgment or miscalculation, rather than from deliberate policy. Department othrr Justice, DD The book claims that the U.
All Europe went on rations for the next three posses, including Britainuntil other losses james bacque food crisis was over. Post war Soviet POW evidence was discredited when the KGB opened its archives in the s and an additionalGerman soldiers and 93, civilians previously recorded as missing were found to be listed as dying in the Soviet camps.
Other Losses by James Bacque
Food in occupied Germany. When it seems so, the price is purchased at the price of accuracy. While Other Losses claims that the United States dismissed the Swiss Government from its role as a protecting power,  Villa states that Bacque ignores that it was the Soviets that had vetoed permitting the other losses james bacque existence of the German government in Mayleaving the Swiss no longer wanting to remain the protecting power because they no longer had a German government to which other losses james bacque report, and that the United Nations—including Canada—had concluded the same.
Facts against Falsehood refuted Bacque’s wily misinterpretations of statistics and oral history evidence in detail.
Waiting for the redirectiron
Ambrose noted that Bacque is a Canadian novelist with no previous historical research or writing experience. Medical Corps reported death rates far higher than they had ever seen before. Bischoff stated that, even in Bacque’s later released American edition, “Bacque refuses to address the overwhelming evidence that there had been a great shortage of food in central Europe, beyond other losses james bacque that there was a food crisis in Germany in ” and “but again he turns the evidence on its head when he charges that ‘Allied food policy [no longer does he heap the blame on the Americas alone, as other losses james bacque his Canadian edition] deliberately hampered the Germans in attempting to feed themselves.
Historian Rolf Steininger stated that Bacque’s claim that the failure to publish the s and s German Maschke Commission finding death figures to be a “cover up” contradicts that the entire 22 volume series was actually published in without any restrictions, to which only an oblique reference is made in an Other Losses endnote. How could the other losses james bacque disappear without one soldier’s coming forward in nearly fifty years to relieve his conscience? Although in his vast indictment, Bacque has included virtually Eisenhower’s entire staff, all the doctors and personnel other losses james bacque the camps, the press who failed to uncover the monstrous crime and a whole generation of knowing but silent Germans, he has included not a single Briton.
Army sent the trains back, saying their own warehouses were full. They are being held in a manner contrary to all humanitarian principles and flagrantly contrary to the Hague and Geneva Conventions.
The effect to give known facts a twist that seems dramatically new in important ways, but this is means appearance of originality is a little deceptive. It seemed to me that, after accounting for transfers and discharges, there was nothing left to make up the grand total except deaths and escapes.
Often during my talk with Mr. Books with missing cover. Few others will do so.
Time Other losses james bacque Monday, Oct. In short, Eisenhower faced shortages even before he learned that there were at least 17 million more people to feed in Germany than he had expected not to mention all of the othre countries in war ravaged Europe, the Philippines, Okinawa and Japan.
Army reports that Bacque states actually reflects a body count of German prisoners that died of slow starvation or diseases.
Other Losses – Wikipedia
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. For the most part, Bacque’s book is not very original at other losses james bacque. Lauben as the source for the claim that the “other losses” weekly report column covered up deaths. He said “Our responsibility for the proper use of relief supplies placed in our bwcque is incompatible with a restriction to the fulfillment of orders which render us powerless to furnish relief which we ourselves judge necessary.
One method was to accuse the Russians of taking far more prisoners than they reported. Bischoff and Ambrose stated that Other Losses states that of Eisenhower, “he felt ashamed llosses he bore a German name”, citing Stephen Ambrose and Colonel Ernest Fisher, when what Ambrose said to Othfr was “It is rumored that Ike once said, ‘I’m ashamed my name is Eisenhower,’ but I’ve never seen it, never used it, other losses james bacque don’t believe it.
Bacque states that he has received letters and phone calls from about 2, Germans who survived the camps, expressing gratitude that the truth about their experience has finally been published. This page was last edited on 19 Juneat In the end, Bacque usually resorts to conspiracy theories to salvage his outrageous charges.
Villa also states that Bacque’s assertion that the British rejected designations to not comply with the GC requirements are entirely other losses james bacque and olsses that jame British themselves requested that they be permitted to use such designations, with that request being granted by the CCS and used in surrenders to British troops. other losses james bacque
So much for Bacque’s careful use of sources. The full text of this book review is only available to subscribers of the London Review of Books.
And they happened at the end of a war we fought for decency and freedom, and they are not excusable.